1901 "I'll Have What G's Having" Cocktail / Georgette Farkas Farkas, Georgette 3 --
1902 Fricassée de Volaille, Escaigots, et Chanterelles au Verjus, Pain Perdu aux Croissants (Chicken, Snails, and Chanterelle Fricassee with Savory Croissant Bread Pudding) / Bradford McDonald McDonald, Bradford 5 --
1903 Rainy Sunday Pork Shoulder with Sesame Cole Slaw / Darin, Greg Bresnitz Bresnitz, Greg 9 --
1904 Whole-Grain Sweet Cherry Crumble (Gluten Free) / Julia Gartland Gartland, Julia 12 --
1905 Roasted Fowl with Shallots, Chanterelle Mushrooms, Garlic Confit, and Vinegar Sauce / Eric Korsh Korsh, Eric, Ginevra Iverson Iverson, Ginevra 15 --
1906 Raspberry-Cured Salmon with Salmon Tarrare, Ginger, and Meyer Lemon / Ben Pollinger Pollinger, Ben 18 --
1907 Braised Beef Cheeks with Carrot Puree, Candy-Stripe Beets, and Tarragon / Leah Cohen Cohen, Leah 21 --
1908 Love Loaf / Zohar Zohar Zohar, Zohar 24 --
1909 Baked Alaska / Travis Post Post, Travis 27 --
1910 The Comet Coupe / Michael Laiskonis Laiskonis, Michael 31 --
1911 Orecchiette with Whiting / Massimiliano Nanni Nanni, Massimiliano 38 --
1912 Quenelles à la Lyonnaise / Jeremiah Tower Tower, Jeremiah 40 --
1913 Chicken au Riesling with Tangerine Salad / Daniel Mattern Mattern, Daniel, Roxana Jullapat Jullapat, Roxana 43 --
1914 "Hifalutin" Cocktail / Del Pedro Pedro, Del 46 --
1915 Cherry Tree Dream Cake / Allison Kave Kave, Allison, Keavy Blueher Blueher, Keavy 49 --
1916 Grandma Hsiang's Shanghainese Zongzi / Danielle Chang Chang, Danielle 51 --
1917 Breaded Pork Chops with Tart Cherry Caraway Port Wine Sauce / Kelly Hogan Hogan, Kelly 55 --
1918 Caldo de Ostiones del 1918 / Barbara Sibley Sibley, Barbara 59 --
1919 Sliced Foie Gras with Buttered Toast Soubise, Blackberry-Port Mostarda, Crispy Pork, and Soft Blue Cheese / Corey Cova Cova, Corey 63 --
1920 "Bye-bye, Albatross" Cocktail / Tiffany Short Short, Tiffany 67 --
1921 Pickled Shrimp and Tomato Aspic Picnic / Keedick Coulter Coulter, Keedick 70 --
1922 The Long Island "Sound Off" / Joe Dobias Dobias, Joe 73 --
1923 Praline Ice Cream with Bourbon Caramel Sauce / Fany Gerson Gerson, Fany 77 --
1924 "I Can't Believe It's the Middle of Winter" Pea Soup / Justin Warner Warner, Justin 81 --
1925 Nana's Skinny Pinnies / Evelyn De Luna Luna, Evelyn De 82 --
1926 Braised Rabbit, Gnocchi, Black Trumpet Mushrooms, Escarole, and American Grana / Stave Dustin Dustin, Stave 85 --
1927 Old-fashioned Salt Cod Cakes / Jasper White White, Jasper 89 --
1928 Sweet Corn "Sunrise" Ravioli, Day Boat Maine Lobster / Marc Foigione Foigione, Marc 92 --
1929 Chicken with Buckwheat Dumplings in a Mushroom Broth / Peter Endriss Endriss, Peter, Chris Pizzulli Pizzulli, Chris 97 --
1930 Lidnivikis / Jenn Louis Louis, Jenn 100 --
1931 Pot Roast Especial a la Gringa / Ivy Stark Stark, Ivy 105 --
1932 "The Sun Also Rises" Punch / Belinda Chang Chang, Belinda 108 --
1933 Roasted Bananas, Three Ways / Gabriella Gershenson Gershenson, Gabriella 111 --
1934 Hot Gin Sling / Nathan Hazard Hazard, Nathan 115 --
1935 Beijing Glass Noodles / José Andrés Andrés, José 116 --
1936 Pear Tarte à la Tatin / Aldo Maiorana Maiorana, Aldo 119 --
1937 Gotham Buckwheat Apple Tart / Chad Robertson Robertson, Chad 121 --
1938 Thanksgiving Turkey with Sausage and Chestnut Sniffing / Elaine Learnard Learnard, Elaine, Ann-Marie Scheidt Scheidt, Ann-Marie 125 --
1939 Grilled Shrimp Pad Thai for Two / Hong Thaimee Thaimee, Hong 131 --
1940 Lemon Coconut Stack Cake / Nicole Taylor Taylor, Nicole 134 --
1941 Gravlax with Caviar and Crème Fraîche / Marcus Samuelsson Samuelsson, Marcus 141 --
1942 Blintz-Krieg Duck (Chinese five-Spice Duck Blintzes with Tart Cherry Sauce) / Michael Harlan Turkell Turkell, Michael Harlan 143 --
1943 "The Américain" Cocktail / Kenneth McCoy McCoy, Kenneth 146 --
1944 Seafood Stew with Tomatoes and Basil / Gail Zweigenthal Zweigenthal, Gail 149 --
1945 Original Brain Tapioca Ambrosia / Shuna Lydon Lydon, Shuna 151 --
1946 Sisig / Noel Cruz Cruz, Noel, Nicole Ponseca Ponseca, Nicole, Miguel Trinidad Trinidad, Miguel 154 --
1947 Konvolute (Danish Fruit-Filled Envelopes) / Beatrice Ojakangas Ojakangas, Beatrice 157 --
1948 Roasted Goose with Matzo Ball Gnocchi and Morels in Sherry Cream Sauce / Joshua Marcus Marcus, Joshua 161 --
1949 Poisson Cru with Sweet Potato and Peanut / Alex Raij Raij, Alex 167 --
1950 Wood Charcoal-Broiled Minute Steak with Creamed Beans, Roasted Potatoes, and a Classic Whiskey Sour / Jason Denton Denton, Jason 168 --
1951 Margo's Rery Roasted Chili and Feta Dip / Paul Lowe Lowe, Paul 175 --
1952 Geraldine's Maryland Crab Soup / Geraldine Cwiek Cwiek, Geraldine 176 --
1953 Beef Wellington / Jesse Schenker Schenker, Jesse 179 --
1954 Grasshopper Icebox Cake / Pichet Ong Ong, Pichet 182 --
1955 Polenta con Ragù di Salsiccia / Michael White White, Michael 185 --
1956 Roasted Leg of Lamb with Mint Salsa Verde / Melissa Clark Clark, Melissa 188 --
1957 Bistecca Chianina / Sara Jenkins Jenkins, Sara 191 --
1958 Crispy Chicken Liver Toast with Cayenne Aioli and Pickle Relish / Ashley Christensen Christensen, Ashley 195 --
1959 Sandkage (Danish Pound Cake) / Barbara Bordnick Bordnick, Barbara 198 --
1960 "Stuffed Bird" / Brad Farmerie Farmerie, Brad 201 --
1961 Stuffed Quail with Grape Sauce / Jacques Pipin Pipin, Jacques 207 --
1962 Boodae Jjigae (Spicy DMZ Stew) / Hooni Kim Kim, Hooni 210 --
1963 Luau Coconut Cocktail / Jeff "Beachbum" Berry Berry, Jeff "Beachbum" 213 --
1964 Kakao Me Mastiha Ke Loukoumas (Mastic-Scented Hot Chocolate and Cinnamon-Sugar Greek Donuts) / Jim Botsacos Botsacos, Jim 216 --
1965 "Electric Gin" Cocktail / Troy Sidle Sidle, Troy 221 --
1966 Sirloin à la Sulu (Pork Sirloin Teppanyaki with Pig Ear Tonkatsu) / David Schuttenberg Schuttenberg, David 222 --
1967 Rose Water Soufflé / Ghaya Oliveira Oliveira, Ghaya 227 --
1968 Tuna Fever / Brian Konopka Konopka, Brian, Salvador Barrera Barrera, Salvador 229 --
1969 The '69 Cocktail with Lamb Chops and Stuffed Mushrooms / Steve Schul Schul, Steve, Paid Zablocki Zablocki, Paid 232 --
1970 Claudia's Crunchy Salad / Claudia Gonson Gonson, Claudia 237 --
1971 "Almost Like Mom's" Macaroni and Cheese / Gael Greene Greene, Gael 241 --
1972 Banoffee Mousse Pie / Ben Mims Mims, Ben 243 --
1973 Fluted Brioches / Sally Dorr Dorr, Sally 246 --
1974 Seventies Key Party Artichoke Crock / Liza Queen Queen, Liza 249 --
1975 Spaghetti Puttanesca (Pasta from the Pantry, aka "Whore-Style") / Silvano Marchetto Marchetto, Silvano 253 --
1976 Firecracker Fourth of July Beef Ribs / Wade Burch Burch, Wade 256 --
1977 Schlutzkrapfen (Austrian Ravioli with Butternut Squash, Sugar Snap Peas, and Pickled Corn) / Eduard Frauneder Frauneder, Eduard, Wolfgang Ban Ban, Wolfgang 259 --
1978 Disco Cake Balls / Rhonda Kave Kave, Rhonda 262 --
1979 Meatball and Potato Pizza / Kemp Minifie Minifie, Kemp 267 --
1980 Apple and Salted Caramel Beignets / Anita Lo Lo, Anita 270 --
1981 Scallop Tiradito with Grapefruit, Hazelnuts, and Watercress / Erik Ramirez Ramirez, Erik 276 --
1982 "Forbidden Fruit" Cocktail / Tom Ricbter Ricbter, Tom 279 --
1983 Matzo Brei / Ruth Reichl Reichl, Ruth 280 --
1984 Hildred's Easy Brooklyn Blackout Cake / Rachel Wharton Wharton, Rachel 283 --
1985 "The Jock," "The Brain," "The Criminal," "The Princess," and "The Basket Case" Cocktails / Robert Krueger Krueger, Robert 286 --
1986 Strawberry Shortstop / Jeremy Spector Spector, Jeremy 289 --
1987 Beef Satay Dumplings / Lucas Lin Lin, Lucas 292 --
1988 Cold Korean Buckwheat Noodles / Scott Hocker Hocker, Scott 295 --
1989 Braised Short Ribs / Kyle MacLachlan MacLachlan, Kyle 298 --
1990 Roasted Broccoli Rarebit with Texas Toast / Alan Sytsma Sytsma, Alan 301 --
1991 Trippa alia Parmigiana / Andrew Carmellini Carmellini, Andrew 306 --
1992 Huevos Diablo / David Duran Duran, David 309 --
1993 Beef Shank Terrine / Daniel Boulud Boulud, Daniel 312 --
1994 Linguine with Clams / Kary Goolsby Goolsby, Kary 315 --
1995 "Mujaddara" Burger with Shiitake Mushrooms, Mint-Chili Pickled Cucumbers, and Smoky Yogurt / Aliya Leekong Leekong, Aliya 318 --
1996 YFC (Yoshi Fried Chicken) / Yoshi Nonaka Nonaka, Yoshi 323 --
1997 Fig-Stuffed Pork Loaf over Mustard Greens with Shallot-Bacon Vinaigrette / Jessica Wilson Wilson, Jessica 325 --
1998 "Spanish Fly" Granita / Shanna Pacifico Pacifico, Shanna 328 --
1999 "Life After Love" Cocktail / Greg Seider Seider, Greg 331 --
2000 Spice-Roasted Venison Chops, Chanterelles, and Blackberries with Kale and Almonds / Michael Lomonaco Lomonaco, Michael 332.